Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Legally Considered “Real”? Understanding U.S. Regulations Before You Buy

The Straight Answer: Yes, They’re “Real Diamonds” — But “Real” Isn’t a Legal Grade

A lab-grown diamond is chemically and structurally a diamond, so in normal U.S. commerce it’s treated as a diamond product—as long as it’s marketed truthfully. Even GIA states lab-grown diamonds are “real” in the sense that they have essentially the same chemical composition and crystal structure as natural diamonds. 

Here’s the part shoppers miss: “Real” is not a protected quality label in U.S. diamond law. What matters legally is whether a seller’s description is accurate and not misleading—especially about origin (lab vs mined). 

What U.S. Regulations Actually Say (FTC = The Big One)

1) The FTC Jewelry Guides set the ground rules for marketing

The FTC’s Jewelry Guides exist to help prevent deceptive claims when selling diamonds and their lab-created or imitation substitutes. They focus on truthful descriptions and disclosure of material information to consumers.

Important nuance (that salespeople will gloss over): these are called “Guides” because they’re guidance, not a criminal code—but the FTC can still act against deceptive advertising under its broader authority.

2) “Diamond” is allowed, but origin must not be hidden

In practice: sellers can call a lab-grown diamond a “diamond,” but they can’t market it in a way that implies it’s mined/natural if it isn’t. The FTC also publishes practical guidance for advertisers on describing diamonds and disclosing material facts.

The One Legal Issue That Actually Gets People Burned: Disclosure

Most disputes don’t happen because the stone “isn’t real.” They happen because:

  • The buyer thought it was mined (or the listing implied it),

  • The paperwork was vague,

  • Or the salesperson played word games (“real diamond” but never said “lab-grown”).

That is exactly what the FTC aims to prevent: misleading descriptions or omitted material information.

Miami Reality Check: Florida Has Its Own Consumer-Protection Hammer

Even if a seller tries to dance around federal guidance, Florida consumers aren’t helpless. Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA) is a state consumer-protection law aimed at deceptive or unfair practices in commerce.

What that means in plain English: if a Miami jeweler’s marketing is misleading (origin, quality, paperwork, “certified” claims), you have state-level angles too—not just “good luck with the FTC.”

What You Should Demand Before Paying (No Exceptions)

If you’re buying in Miami (or anywhere), your minimum standard should be:

  1. A grading/identification report from a recognized lab

    • And you verify the report number yourself on the lab’s system when possible. 

  2. Clear wording that it’s laboratory-grown

    • Not “diamond” alone, not “eco diamond,” not “alternative diamond.”

  3. A written return policy

    • If the seller resists putting it in writing, that’s your sign.

  4. An insurance-ready appraisal that explicitly states lab-grown

    • Insurance/appraisal contexts need clarity because lab-grown vs mined affects valuation expectations.

The Hard Truth: “Legally Real” Doesn’t Mean “Financially Equivalent”

Lab-grown diamonds can be authentic diamonds while still having:

  • different resale dynamics,

  • different market pricing volatility,

  • different appraisal outcomes.

So don’t let anyone use “real” as a closer. It’s a chemistry statement, not a value guarantee.

Back to News